And if you thought insurance companies only shafted people in the flood zone….

Think again Buttercup. Pearl River Community College. located around 40 miles away from the coast in Poplarville is still figthting their private insurer Zurich to cover Katrina losses under their wind policy. Here is a hint for Dr Lewis, you’re wasting your time with endless arbitrations. If the institutions policy has an appraisal provision use it.

sop

Double Trouble Doubled Down – Kuehn v State Farm

Remember the Kuehn’s of Double Trouble Kuehn v State Farm?

On February 28, 2008, the appraisal process concluded, and the umpire and the parties’ appraisers signed an Award setting forth the appraisal amount of $174,811.80…counsel for State Farm Fire told the appraisers and the umpire that the Award did not specify which part was for wind…the appraisers and umpire rewrote the Award to indicate that the entire amount was for wind damage.

Well, I ran into their case when I was looking at recent filings and decided to take a look and see how things were going.

We left them back in February shortly after Counsel for Plaintiffs learned during the deposition of State Farm’s designated appraiser, John Minor, on or about February 6, 2009, that counsel for State Farm will be, at the very least, necessary and material witnesses in this action. Counsel for State Farm recognized this fact and the deposition was halted.

John Banahan had just stepped in as new counsel for State Farm and requested an extension on the period of discovery on the appraisal issue until March 31 that would move the deadline for motions back to mid-April.

What happened between then and now would be easier to explain if this case had not bounced between state and federal court twice since  Hurricane Katrina. Wait, I take that back!  Let’s take a closer look at this case.

Hurricane Katrina ravaged their insured property, causing destruction to the structure and its contents.  On September 27, 2005 an adjuster for State Farm inspected the property.  The time line and documents that follow tell the story.

January 4, 2006
State Farm Fire…informed Plaintiffs that it would not cover the loss beyond what was already paid, which was $10,765.48.pages-from-kuehn-v-state-farm-41

April I, 2006 Continue reading “Double Trouble Doubled Down – Kuehn v State Farm”