Breaking: Department of Homeland Security OIG: Insurers We Have a Problem

I’m working out and am on a very slow internet connection so I’ll be very brief.  Here is the report and following is U.S. representative Gene Taylor’s comments:

The Inspector General’s Office found errors in 62 of the 131 flood claims it investigated. In more than one-third of the cases, the errors were related to the cause of damage. In two cases, the files included material evidence that ‘clearly identified wind as the preponderant cause of damage, thus resulting in an improper payment by NFIP in the amount of $432,600.’ If the files reviewed by the IOG are representative of the total of more than 165,000 NFIP claims from Hurricane Katrina, then NFIP may have paid for wind damage in 2,500 claims for more than $500 million.

“The report also acknowledged ‘difficulties in distinguishing between wind and flood damage when they occur concurrently, and especially when there is nothing remaining except a foundation (slab).’ However, I am very disappointed that the Inspector General’s Office did not demand that the insurance companies explain their procedures for allocating damage where there was not enough physical evidence remaining to prove how much was caused by wind and how much was caused by water. NFIP’s refusal to insist on fair procedures to allocate losses caused by both wind and water allowed insurance companies to claim all of the benefit of the doubt in their favor. After Katrina, this allowed insurers to bill the taxpayers any damage that might have been caused by flooding, while paying for wind damage only where there was physical proof that the loss was not caused by flooding.

“The Inspector General’s report does confirm the poor oversight by NFIP. No other federal program allows private companies that have a conflict of interest to hand out checks from the federal government for up to $350,000 with almost no accountability.

Amen Brother Gene! It is way past time the fox was banned from the henhouse.


4 thoughts on “Breaking: Department of Homeland Security OIG: Insurers We Have a Problem”

  1. My guess, Rick, because Congress was still in session and this report would have increased the likelihood HR3121 would be called up and passed – and the President was opposed to the legislation.

    I’ve been working on a related post that I’ll put up over the weekend as this report fills a lot of gaps.

  2. We’ll another answer it is not in the news is because this version of modern finance (the insurance version) masquerading as an over sized ponzi scheme is not going to cost the American the public the equivalent of the direct funding costs of the entire Iraq war.

    The entire cost of Katrina seems to be currently measuring somewhere around the $100 Billion mark: a plausible number as it would mean that she fits very well within the expected geometric compression (being around twice the next largest).

    Taleb of the Black Swan fame recently noted that our banking system has lost more money in the debacle then the entire banking has ever earned in cumulative profits: ever. Ever as in since Adam met Eve.

  3. Your comment makes me want to hurry and finish my related post-in-progress as it lays out the Ponzi scheme of the insurance version – look forward to your comments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *